Classic Patrick Berry, a smooth 68-worder filled with a ton of solid entries. I appreciate the "classic" feel of PB themelesses, ...
read moreClassic Patrick Berry, a smooth 68-worder filled with a ton of solid entries. I appreciate the "classic" feel of PB themelesses, nothing that's faddish; that will be forgotten a year or even a month from now. I also like that he takes great care to incorporate a variety of answers into his work, aiming to give a little something to just about everyone. From the old-time LOUIS PRIMA to a more modern THE OMEN (with a great clue, referencing its ominous 6/6/06 release date!), from the 13th century classical STABAT MATER to the colloquial EVEN STEVEN … what nice range.

I enjoy seeing PB's experimentation in themelesses, almost always something new that he's trying out. Today he features a stair-stack of five long entries, a great quint featuring TWEENAGERS, NAIL SALONS, JOB TITLES. As usual, his grids have some neutral-ish entries like CHARACTERS — a bit dull since it's kind of a pedestrian word in everyday language — but also as usual, he elevates those with clever clues. [Book collection?] indeed hints at the CHARACTERS making up a book's cast.
PB is one of a very small handful of people who can pull off 68-word grids without resorting to the crutch of dabbing crossword glue here and there. So it was a little surprising to see AT SEA, ESTER, HIE today. These are very minor uglies, ones that would hardly register with me if this was anyone but PB. I have such a high bar for him though.
Also sticking out a bit is some lost potential in cluing. [It goes station to station] for FUEL TANKER was pretty good, but it felt like it could have misdirected much more sneakily to radio or other types of stations. ICEMAN ... [Nerves-of-steel type] felt like awkward usage. I'd have much preferred a clue referring to any one of the people given that awesome nickname over the years.
FYI, FRAN refers to "Kukla, Fran, and Ollie," an old TV show where Kukla and Ollie were puppets.
But overall, another smooth and classic 68-word puzzle from the master.