It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker. Please consider supporting our site by purchasing an account.

New York Times, Tuesday, April 28, 2015

Author: José Chardiet
Editor: Will Shortz
TotalDebutLatestCollabs
37/6/20104/28/20150
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
0030000
ScrabbleRebusCirclePangram
1.68011
José Chardiet

This puzzle:

Rows: 15, Columns: 15 Words: 78, Blocks: 40 Missing: {JWYZ} This is puzzle # 3 for Mr. Chardiet. NYT links: Across Lite PDF
Jeff Chen notes: Ambitious effort, packing in a whopping 14 instances of SQUARE ROOTS, i.e. the letters R O O T arranged into squares. Each one of ... more
Jeff Chen notes:

Ambitious effort, packing in a whopping 14 instances of SQUARE ROOTS, i.e. the letters R O O T arranged into squares. Each one of these appearances constrains the grid by reducing one's flexibility in the intersecting across and down answers. So to have 14 — some of them right next to each other! — is audacious indeed.

Just to get a grid like this filled is pretty impressive (from a constructor's standpoint), so I really appreciated José's incorporation of some nice entries. CABOOSES is already a pretty colorful word, and the clue is genius. [Ones back on track?] refers to that fact that CABOOSES are the last cars on trains. And PET DOOR is a beauty of an answer, especially considering 7-letter entries often come out neutral or blah. Loved the funny [What a dog might raise a flap about?] clue.

Going out for a while, BRB

I found the visual impact of the circles (on the Across Lite version) overwhelming, a bit like staring at a flashing neon sign in Vegas or staring into the sun. The shaded squares as seen in print (and below) are so much nicer — all those spots before my eyes felt jarring; making it difficult to simply enter letters.

It would have been great to have a rationale for 14 instances. I think I would have been more pleased if it had been nine instances, sort of spaced out in a 3x3 array. Although the number nine isn't special (in that every integer is the square root of something), a 3x3 grid feels more like it fits the theme concept.

Having fewer instances would have also allowed for cleaner fill. I really like the creativity of … OR IS IT? but the combination of so many three-letter words and quite a bit of gluey entries made for a choppy solve.

All in all though, it's hard to argue with a crossword involving a GOON TOUR.

1
C
2
B
3
C
4
D
5
O
6
G
7
O
8
O
9
D
10
S
11
T
12
P
13
T
O
A
14
E
G
O
T
R
I
15
P
16
P
O
O
17
R
O
B
18
E
R
O
S
I
V
E
19
I
R
T
20
B
O
21
R
D
E
N
22
S
A
G
23
E
T
E
A
24
T
O
O
T
S
25
T
26
R
I
S
27
B
A
R
T
28
R
O
S
E
29
F
O
O
T
30
M
E
T
O
O
31
U
S
E
32
C
L
U
B
33
S
O
R
34
S
35
Q
U
A
R
E
36
R
O
O
T
37
S
38
U
S
B
39
R
O
A
R
40
E
41
P
42
A
43
S
44
N
45
O
O
P
46
S
T
O
P
47
A
T
O
R
48
T
O
R
T
49
D
E
A
F
50
P
I
L
O
T
51
R
O
P
E
52
D
I
N
53
T
54
R
E
M
O
R
55
U
G
H
56
P
E
T
57
D
O
O
R
58
O
T
59
T
60
C
I
A
61
S
T
R
O
P
H
E
62
S
A
N
63
K
E
N
64
S
A
S
S
E
S
65
E
X
T
© 2015, The New York TimesNo. 0428 ( 23,912 )
Across Down
1. North-of-the-border media inits. : CBC
4. Contribute to society : DOGOOD
10. Pit crew's canful : STP
13. ___ point : TOA
14. Self-promotional autobiography, for its writer : EGOTRIP
16. Icky-___ (awful, in baby talk) : POO
17. Steal from : ROB
18. Like waves vis-à-vis the shoreline : EROSIVE
19. N.Y.C. subway line : IRT
20. Elsie the Cow's brand : BORDEN
22. Healthful herbal beverage : SAGETEA
24. Honey : TOOTS
25. Speaker in the Baseball Hall of Fame : TRIS
27. Cartoon character voiced by Nancy Cartwright : BART
28. Got off the ground? : ROSE
29. Locale for tarsals and metatarsals : FOOT
30. "Same here" : METOO
31. Take advantage of : USE
32. Night life setting : CLUB
33. Sisters' grp. : SOR
34. Math calculations exemplified 14 times in this puzzle : SQUAREROOTS
38. Kind of port : USB
39. 2013 #1 Katy Perry hit : ROAR
40. Org. that might employ a climatologist : EPA
43. Busybody : SNOOP
46. "Hold it!" : STOP
47. Suffix with liquid : ATOR
48. Trespassing, for one : TORT
49. Dependent on subtitles, say : DEAF
50. Frequent flier : PILOT
51. Lured, as a potential customer : ROPEDIN
53. Minor seismic movement : TREMOR
55. "Yuck!" : UGH
56. What a dog might raise a flap about? : PETDOOR
58. The Senators, on sports tickers : OTT
60. "The Bourne Identity" org. : CIA
61. Poetic stanza : STROPHE
62. ___ José : SAN
63. Author Kesey : KEN
64. Gets fresh with : SASSES
65. Abbr. after a telephone number : EXT
1. Point of convergence: Abbr. : CTR
2. Owies : BOOBOOS
3. Ones back on track? : CABOOSES
4. Monopoly pile : DEEDS
5. Fairy tale villain : OGRE
6. Hit the road, as a band : GOONTOUR
7. Exciting parts of games, for short : OTS
8. Question that leaves an opening for doubt : ORISIT
9. Spotlight seekers : DIVAS
10. Show utter contempt for : SPITAT
11. Entertainer with a cape : TORERO
12. Common gnocchi ingredient : POTATO
15. Good name for a baseball pitcher? : PEG
21. U.P.S. driver's assignment: Abbr. : RTE
23. "Your Movie Sucks" author : EBERT
24. ___TV (Time Warner channel) : TRU
26. Vocalist Flack : ROBERTA
29. Exerciser's target : FLAB
30. Tie up, as a ship : MOOR
32. Brink : CUSP
33. "The Young and the Restless," e.g. : SOAP
35. Not a paraphrase : QUOTE
36. Places to view fireworks : ROOFTOPS
37. Release, as the hounds : SETLOOSE
41. Chance card in Monopoly with a $15 fee : POORTAX
42. Murals, e.g. : ART
43. Smacked : STRUCK
44. Painful bit of horseplay : NOOGIE
45. James of "James and the Giant Peach," for one : ORPHAN
46. Nissan model : SENTRA
47. Adjust an arrow, say : AIM
49. Demanding film role preparations : DIETS
50. Israel's Shimon : PERES
52. Producers of two outs, for short : DPS
54. Architect Ludwig Mies van der ___ : ROHE
57. Cuban couple : DOS
59. Stick with a fuse : TNT

Answer summary: 3 unique to this puzzle, 1 debuted here and reused later, 1 unique to Shortz Era but used previously.

Found bugs or have suggestions?