For a while, I got obsessed with survival shows. For a while, it was Bear Grylls, but then Survivor Man came onto the scene. Les ...
read moreFor a while, I got obsessed with survival shows. For a while, it was Bear Grylls, but then Survivor Man came onto the scene. Les Stroud out there, all by himself, with only a FLINT. Then it was a single MATCH. When ratings dipped, he stripped it back to just some TINDER. I kept wondering what the natural conclusion would be — starting a fire with a MATCHBOX CAR? I'd watch that!
I hitched at the end, wondering why a MATCHBOX would be a FIRE STARTER. Or was that supposed to be a MATCH, overlooking the fact that MATCHBOX is one word? I spent a long time debating the merits of something like MATCH POINTS vs. an entire MATCHBOX of matches being better in the wild—
Somewhere, Les Stroud is crying.
AMARO crossing AMI right off the bat could be fraught with peril. Both of these entries are so constructor-friendly, alternating vowel-consonant, and common letters to boot. However, if you don't know much French and aren't a drinker (one spirits aficionado I asked said that AMARO is niche at best), it could be a killer crossing for newer solvers. At least a clue like ["Who ___ to judge?"] would have helped.
Over at Crosswords with Friends (Zynga), they've done studies to measure retention, and one of the things they've noted is that if someone can't get 1-Across, there's a good chance they won't continue. I wouldn't apply that wholesale to the NYT solving audience, but I think it's a principle to keep in mind when constructing.
I did enjoy a lot of the great TRIPWIRE, LAS VEGAS / PLAYDATE (what a combination!) bonuses. The slightly odd SYNTAXES plural and LPS were reasonable prices to pay.
Tight concept, hard to imagine any other possible themers. I'm curious to see what the solver feedback is like for that NW corner — elated because you're an AMARO drinker? Angry because you got that crossing wrong? Pleased to learn something new? Unsatisfied because AMARO looked like it couldn't possibly be a correct string of letters? I bet Will Shortz would hear all four responses, but what would be most interesting to me is in what proportions.