Constructors are sneaky. Ever wonder why the word SMILE has appeared in about 150 Shortz-era crosswords, while FROWN is stuck at 14? Subtle influencing through theme choices and grid fill nudges solvers' moods without them even knowing. The fools!
Huh? It's because SMILE is packed with common letters, while FROWN contains harder-to-work-with F and W?
:-(
Uplifting, a puzzle all about TOPs and PEAKs (although, HEIGHT doesn't fit as well). Apt theme for Andrea Carla Michaels (née Eisenberg), who goes by the moniker Acme!
Who doesn't love the ACME CORPORATION, too, what with its Iron Carrots and Earthquake Pills. Well, there's Wile E. Coyote ... who has wily worked WILE 71 times into the NYT crossword!
I'm curious what percentage of solvers will notice the theme today. Some don't even know that there are themes, period, and if there's no revealer to point to what's going on … will some think that this is an Alex TREBEK tribute puzzle, one of the BIG SHOTS in the game show world, eliciting PEAK PERFORMANCES from mere mortals, riding his jet-propelled unicycle on stage.
Maybe COVID isolation is getting to me.
A puzzle with four grid-spanners can be hairy, especially at the ends of the two middle themers. Exhibit A: the south region, with ESSEN / MBE. N???I is a rough pattern, with few valid options, so that restricts flexibility. Perhaps switching HEIGHT OF FASHION and TOP OF THE MORNING would have helped since ING is a friendlier ending to work with than ION (five-letter words ending with O aren't as common as those ending with N).
Alan and Acme could have made their lives easier by picking shorter themers, like PEAK CONDITION, TOP OF THE LINE, etc., but I appreciated that they went full 15 since that puts all ACME synonyms at the top of the puzzle. (Mirror symmetry would have allowed them to use APEX PREDATOR at the top, though.)
A couple of trade-offs, some smoothing they could have done (AERO, ACAB, ERG, etc.) but overall, a reasonable Monday offering, if not top of the line.