It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker. Please consider supporting our site by purchasing an account.
This web browser is not supported. Use Chrome, Edge, Safari, or Firefox for best results.

New York Times, Thursday, November 23, 2017

Author:
Howard Barkin
Editor:
Will Shortz
TotalDebutLatestCollabs
97/23/201410/6/20191
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2202111
ScrabbleRebusCirclePangram
1.64100
Howard Barkin

This puzzle:

Rows: 15, Columns: 15 Words: 78, Blocks: 38 Missing: {FQZ} This is puzzle # 5 for Mr. Barkin. NYT links: Across Lite PDF
Howard Barkin notes:
Hello solvers, hope that this one wasn't too rough on you. All comments on my puzzles are welcomed, in any forum that you choose. ... read more

Hello solvers, hope that this one wasn't too rough on you. All comments on my puzzles are welcomed, in any forum that you choose.

The phrase "halftime show" combined with "60 minutes" was the seed for this puzzle; it took much longer to decide upon the actual theme, combining a mathematical multiplication/division with some form or reference to a creative work.

Bonus note: I did initially seek a "quarter" clue instead of "fourth", but I could not really find an appropriate "quarter" phrase that met the full theme.

Someone may likely find a perfect fit for this, but in the end I decided that "fourth estate" was the best and most cluable option, if slightly inelegant for "one-fourth".

Jeff Chen notes:
Mathplay! Some beautiful finds, like [Double feature?] interpreted as 'double the number in a feature film,' turning 'Three Amigos' ... read more

Mathplay! Some beautiful finds, like [Double feature?] interpreted as "double the number in a feature film," turning "Three Amigos" into SIX AMIGOS. And [Halftime show] as "halve the time in a show," creating THIRTY MINUTES out of "60 Minutes." THIRTY MINUTES would be much more appropriate for us short-attention span people LOOK, SOMETHING SHINY!

Ahem. I was proud of myself for getting RICHARD … something. IX? IV? Okay fine, I didn't read "Richard II" when I was supposed to.

What, it's "Richard III"?

I knew that.

It took me a while to figure out THE JACKSON ONE. What's a "fifth act," I wondered? The … fifth act of a play? Is it like a third wheel, in that final act of a play that JUST WON'T END?

Maybe "Richard II"?

But that "fifth act" business was the only one that didn't play on a common, in-the-language phrase, so some good finds overall.

Okay, I was still confused on [Fourth estate?] hours after solving. Did that mean … fourth in a series of estates? Is there something called "Zero Oaks," so THREE OAKS is the 4th, using zero-based indexing? (Man, I'm a nerd.) Or take one-fourth of something called "Twelve Oaks"? Huh.

Ah, right. There's something called "Twelve Oaks" in "Gone with the Wind." Huh.

I didn't notice until the very end that Howard formed a sequence with his themers! Well. Kinda. Sorta. If you squint. It's 1/2, x2, x3, 1/4, 1/5.

*squinting harder*

Oh, 13-letter themers, you pains in constructors' patooties. Notice how Howard had to put the first and last themers in rows 4 / 12 instead of the usual 3 / 13? Crunches things up, but good! And with that central 9 splitting the puzzle in half, forcing big corners … oof, that's so tough to construct around. It's no wonder there's a bunch of OCTO, HEA, ANET, AMAS, ESE, etc.

Too much crossword glue to feel like an elegant product, but I can understand the decision to achieve the sequence(ish) of themers, which forces a terribly difficult arrangement of themers. I might have chosen to go more randomly, thus opening up more themer possibilities, especially with the movie and the play. And maybe dropping THREE OAKS.

Overall, a bit kooky with some blips in most aspects of puzzle design, but an interesting idea that made me think.

1
W
2
R
3
A
4
P
5
M
6
O
7
V
8
I
9
E
10
J
11
I
12
V
13
E
14
H
E
R
O
15
E
B
E
R
T
16
O
R
A
L
17
I
S
T
O
18
R
A
N
A
T
19
D
E
C
K
20
T
H
I
R
21
T
Y
M
I
N
U
22
T
E
S
23
E
O
S
24
A
L
A
25
A
C
I
26
D
27
Y
28
N
O
T
29
O
K
30
S
31
I
32
X
33
A
M
I
G
O
S
34
S
T
E
R
E
35
O
36
S
E
N
37
N
H
L
38
R
I
C
39
H
A
R
D
40
I
41
X
42
A
43
P
44
B
45
T
E
A
46
S
M
I
47
L
48
E
49
D
50
T
H
R
51
E
52
E
O
A
K
53
S
54
A
S
A
M
I
55
E
D
I
T
S
56
O
57
M
G
58
W
A
N
59
T
H
E
60
J
61
A
62
C
K
S
O
63
N
O
N
E
64
I
65
N
C
A
66
A
C
R
I
D
67
A
M
A
S
68
M
O
O
N
69
B
R
U
N
O
70
D
A
T
A
71
O
N
M
E
72
S
E
E
D
S
73
A
N
E
T
© 2017, The New York TimesNo. 1123 ( 24,852 )
Across
1
Completion of filming : WRAP
5
"Se7en," "Nine" or "10" : MOVIE
10
Phony talk : JIVE
14
"My ___!" : HERO
15
Onetime reviewer of 5-Acrosses : EBERT
16
Kind of argument : ORAL
17
: : ISTO
18
Rushed : RANAT
19
Set of 108 for Uno : DECK
20
Halftime show? : THIRTYMINUTES
23
Bringer of light, in myth : EOS
24
Start of a well-known roll call: Abbr. : ALA
25
A little sharp : ACIDY
28
Unacceptable : NOTOK
30
Double feature? : SIXAMIGOS
34
What plays to both sides? : STEREO
36
Booker or Tester: Abbr. : SEN
37
Toronto and Ottawa are in it, for short : NHL
38
Triple play? : RICHARDIX
42
Radioed info, for short : APB
45
After-dinner option : TEA
46
Looked favorably (upon) : SMILED
50
Fourth estate? : THREEOAKS
54
"Me too," more formally : ASAMI
55
Things thsi cluee needs sevaral of : EDITS
56
"Wow!" : OMG
58
Unhealthy-looking : WAN
59
Fifth act? : THEJACKSONONE
64
Smallpox victims of the 1500s : INCA
66
Sharp : ACRID
67
Good word to know if you love Latin? : AMAS
68
A new one is nearly invisible : MOON
69
The star Mars : BRUNO
70
___ point : DATA
71
Words of generosity : ONME
72
Sometimes they're the pits : SEEDS
73
Work without ___ : ANET
Down
1
Bleaches : WHITENS
2
Do another take : RESHOOT
3
Virtuoso : ARTISTE
4
D : POOR
5
Actress Streep : MERYL
6
Former White House family : OBAMAS
7
Start of a Julius Caesar quote : VENI
8
Locale of 10% of the world's oil reserves : IRAN
9
Start of a Julius Caesar quote : ETTU
10
Group with five #1 R&B hits in the 1990s : JODECI
11
Declaration at the end of a chess game : IRESIGN
12
Closet item, for short : VAC
13
Higher-priced burger meat : ELK
21
Original "Star Trek" cast member : TAKEI
22
Bit of doctoral graduation regalia : TAM
26
"Silly me!" : DOH
27
Fashion inits. : YSL
29
Youngest player ever to win the Calder Memorial Trophy : ORR
31
Singer Chris : ISAAK
32
Many a fortysomething, for short : XER
33
Extra conditions : ANDS
35
Numerical prefix : OCTO
39
"Wasn't ___ most peculiar man?" (Simon & Garfunkel lyric) : HEA
40
Stage after pupa : IMAGO
41
They follow the nus : XIS
42
Broke fast? : ATE
43
High degree : PHD
44
"The Office," originally : BRITCOM
47
1971 double-platinum album for the Doors : LAWOMAN
48
Flow (from) : EMANATE
49
Patronizes, in a way : DINESAT
51
C2H6, familiarly : ETHANE
52
Suffix with journal : ESE
53
Extremely considerate : SOKIND
57
Precursor to Windows : MSDOS
60
Quick hits : JABS
61
4,046.86 square meters : ACRE
62
Rock's Mötley ___ : CRUE
63
Nothin' : NADA
64
Opening for a personal view : IMO
65
Prefix with G.M.O. : NON

Answer summary: 7 unique to this puzzle, 1 unique to Shortz Era but used previously.

Found bugs or have suggestions?