Original 25-Across had "pumpkin," but the line in the poem by James Whitcomb Riley is "The frost is on the punkin . . . "; corrected this.
1 L  | 2 I  | 3 V  | 4 E  | 5 O  | 6 N  | 7 L  | 8 I  | 9 T  | 10 T  | 11 L  | 12 E  | 
		|||
13 O  | N  | A  | N  | D  | O  | 14 N  | 15 B  | E  | N  | A  | R  | E  | S  | 
		|
16 S  | A  | N  | T  | O  | N  | A  | 17 A  | T  | O  | N  | I  | C  | S  | 
		|
18 S  | S  | T  | 19 R  | E  | I  | 20 N  | S  | I  | N  | 21 E  | T  | E  | 
		||
22 E  | T  | A  | 23 H  | 24 S  | L  | A  | I  | N  | 25 I  | S  | O  | N  | 
		||
26 S  | E  | G  | A  | 27 R  | 28 E  | T  | C  | 29 S  | N  | O  | R  | E  | 
		||
30 W  | E  | T  | H  | 31 E  | R  | S  | 32 S  | I  | G  | N  | S  | |||
33 E  | E  | L  | Y  | 34 M  | U  | L  | E  | |||||||
35 A  | 36 W  | F  | U  | L  | 37 L  | I  | E  | O  | N  | 38 I  | 39 T  | |||
40 H  | O  | H  | U  | M  | 41 S  | O  | S  | 42 S  | U  | M  | U  | 43 P  | 
		||
44 O  | R  | E  | L  | 45 F  | L  | O  | S  | 46 S  | 47 E  | I  | R  | E  | 
		||
48 O  | A  | R  | 49 E  | R  | E  | M  | I  | T  | 50 E  | 51 T  | N  | T  | 
		||
52 K  | N  | E  | 53 L  | L  | E  | D  | 54 L  | A  | W  | 55 C  | A  | S  | E  | 
		|
56 E  | G  | O  | I  | S  | T  | S  | 57 E  | R  | E  | C  | T  | O  | R  | 
		|
58 R  | I  | N  | S  | E  | S  | 59 T  | R  | I  | E  | N  | S  | 
		
Answer summary:
3 unique to this puzzle, 10 debuted here and reused later,  4 appeared only in pre-Shortz puzzles.
Found bugs or have suggestions? Please let us know.
Crosswords published prior to Nov. 21, 1993 are provided by David Steinberg and The Pre-Shortzian Puzzle Project.