I imagine plenty of people will think this grid is asymmetrical, but it exhibits a rare diagonal symmetry. I love it when people shift ...
read moreI imagine plenty of people will think this grid is asymmetrical, but it exhibits a rare diagonal symmetry. I love it when people shift crossword norms. If you tilt your head 45 to the right, notice that the grid now looks like it has mirror symmetry. Cool!
(Note: Will Shortz has put the kibosh on two of my up-down symmetry submissions, based purely on aesthetic reasons, so I'd advise against it.)
It's not simply novel, but diagonal symmetry opens up new possibilities, like two marquee answers crossing (OUT OF LEFT FIELD and INSIDE BASEBALL) while allowing easy separation of stacks (PALO ALTO / PROUDEST / SITTERS and BACARDI / BANK LOAN / AGUILERA).
One drawback is that there's the potential for a single hard-to-fill corner, like the southwest. Most editors ixnay 6-letter partials like AS PURE, so it didn't shine as much as the rest of the puzzle.
So much cluing wordplay shined through. TOQUES are literally over (the chef's) head in restaurants. A BANK LOAN as something "of interest." "Running apparel" had me confused, but what a great a-ha moment when I realized it referred to HOSE that gets runs after snags.
Brooke is a big proponent for more diverse representation in crosswords, and I appreciated the touches that made me interested without feeling like I was being forced to learn. I don't know MARI Copeny, but it was easy enough to fill in from the crosses, and the "Little Miss Flint" reference made me curious to read up on her. A great teacher creates a situation where you want to learn, and Brooke did that so well.
There was a bit of ESSE, INAT, CFC (chlorofluorocarbon), ROES (strange in plural), but nothing egregious. CADENT made this musician pause, but it is a word in the dictionary.
I appreciate that this isn't the standard Friday offering. It wasn't only the diagonal symmetry that made it feel fresh, but some of the entries and especially the thoughtful cluing.