The inspiration for this puzzle came from Matt Gaffney's meta-puzzles, which I enjoy very much. Every so often, he addresses the solver directly in the puzzle as part of the meta, and although at first I found it strange, it kind of grew on me, so I decided to make a non-meta puzzle that included direct address. I was rather pleased when I realized that the different GET phrases all exist. The big challenge, though, was that GET up and GET down aren't as symmetric as they feel like they should be, making it quite hard to construct a symmetric grid.
In spite of the initial difficulty, the fill came out okay, and I enjoyed the cluing. 10-A, 52-A, and 28-D were my favorite clues, along with the matched pair at 39-A and 34-D. Solvers might be interested to know that my original version was a bit more difficult, with the GET phrases not given but clued, so 18-A would have been clued as "Gripping read ['Don't stand so close']," 24-A would have been "Oil containers ['Show us your funky dance moves!']," etc. I guess that Will decided that it would be too difficult or weird that way.
As always, I hope that solvers enjoyed the puzzle.
Just a few days ago, I suggested to a prospective constructor that Will doesn't often run puzzles with entries that look crazy. Shows what I know! ABRIDOOFAR is A BRIDGE TOO FAR + "Get lost!" (an instruction to lose GET) = ABRIDOOFAR. GET is treated differently in the other three themers, which I've highlighted. Tricky theme! PATEGURNER took me forever to uncover because of how weird it looks. Good a-ha moment when I realized how it fit with the theme (GET is literally entered in "Get back!" fashion, or TEG).
I always appreciate getting something I've never seen before, and the mechanics of this theme was pretty cool. I wish the phrases in parentheses ("Get back!", for example) had been tied to the clues or the answers somehow though, like if instead of PAGE TURNER, Victor had found a themer which had the *TEG* sequence which meant "Get back!" That's likely way too much to ask for, but it would have made a pretty cool idea the bomb dot com.
What a wild looking layout today, eh? Any time you have themers "bending," the fill becomes more difficult, and since two of the themers "bend" twice, it becomes even more difficult. Victor does go over the 78-word limit (80 slots today, although four get melded into others for a total of 76 entries), but he still manages to give us a couple of really nice pieces of long fill, CONGOLESE, JEZEBEL and WRIT LARGE being my favorite. What a neat phrase, that last one.
One issue I had was the segmented nature of the north and south regions. It's usually best if the puzzle has a more connected, flowing feel (more than just one way into a section), because if a solver gets stuck, he/she really gets stuck. That's what happened to me in the south today, unable to see AFORE what with the opaque cluing for the crossing answers. It also seemed to me that with such a closed-off section with little constraint, a better answer than AFORE could have been used. Who knows though, often times a constructor has a particular affinity for a particular word, and that's okay by me as long as it's intentional.
It sure is nice to get the Thursday workout. Will tends to switch things up so there are some easier ones (with more straightforward themes but difficult cluing) and there are some harder ones (mind-bending or rule-breaking themes). I'll almost always favor the latter, but I do appreciate the variety.
80 words? You'd think that by looking at the grid but it depends how you count. There are 76 sets of clues and answers. Some bend.
1 T | 2 A | 3 L | 4 E | 5 S | 6 Q | 7 U | 8 A | 9 B | 10 A | 11 C | 12 D | 13 C |
||
14 A | L | E | X | 15 O | U | N | C | E | 16 D | O | R | A |
||
17 P | I | N | T | 18 P | A | T | E | G | 19 U | R | N | E | R |
|
20 A | S | T | O | 21 R | 22 D | O | S | 23 R | E | G | A | L |
||
24 S | T | O | R | A | G | 26 I | G | N | O | R | E |
|||
27 T | H | E | 28 M | 29 S | T | E | A | L | ||||||
30 B | 31 M | 32 W | S | T | A | 34 N | K | S | 35 L | E | 36 A | 37 K |
||
38 A | I | R | 39 Y | O | U | 40 S | K | I |
||||||
41 A | X | I | 42 S | T | O | W | N | 44 S | 45 J | E | A | N |
||
46 T | A | 47 S | E | R | 48 K | A | 49 L | E | ||||||
50 C | 51 O | L | L | E | G | 52 G | A | Z | 53 E | 54 B | 55 O |
|||
56 O | R | A | T | E | 57 T | 58 U | 59 B | 60 S | E | V | E | R |
||
61 A | B | R | I | D | 62 O | O | F | A | 63 R | 64 B | I | G | A |
|
65 T | I | G | E | 66 A | F | O | R | E | 67 E | T | A | L |
||
68 S | T | E | R | 69 F | U | S | E | D | 70 L | E | N | S |
Answer summary: 3 unique to this puzzle.
Found bugs or have suggestions?