I thought all six of the longest answers were great. Just for kicks, I'm going to rank them. (Warning, subjective analysis ahead!) TOP ...
read moreI thought all six of the longest answers were great. Just for kicks, I'm going to rank them. (Warning, subjective analysis ahead!)

TOP TIER
- NASAL STRIPS. It's a fantastic entry on its own, and recognizable even if you've never used one (they used to be advertised on TV all the time). Even better, the clue is pure gold! [Things used on bridges to ease congestion] so innocently deflects to medians, lane-dividers, etc. I loved the entire puzzle based on this entry/clue alone.
- TUPPERWARE PARTY. Again, sizzling entry, sizzling clue. Such a funny image of a bacchanalian party with people belching like airhorns. Nope, burping your Tupperware!
MIDDLE TIER
- AIRPORT CODE. Nice phrase, and some misdirect potential. JFK might have made you think about the President first?
- SO FAR SO GOOD. Solid entry, colloquial, fun. As a phrase, I like it better than AIRPORT CODE. But here's the thing: there's not a lot of potential for clever cluing. "No issues yet" is equivalent, but there's not nearly the click I got from the two top-tier clues. For this reason, I put AIRPORT CODE above it.
BOTTOM TIER
- Don't get me wrong, I still enjoyed these two a lot. But WAYNES WORLD is over 15 years ago. Is it a classic? I think so — this fan calls it ex-cellent! But I'm not sure for how many others it causes the same elation.
- NED FLANDERS. Again, I'm a Simpsons fan, so I'm more than hi-diddly-o-kay with this one. But there are plenty of people for whom this one won't do much. Jim for instance — I think he'd be able to fill in the letters, but never having seen the Simpsons, what does it do for him?
I started making xws about 10 years ago, and my views on what's "good" and "not" have changed a lot — interesting that my evolution mirrors that of Andrew's. I would have put WAYNES WORLD and SO FAR SO GOOD on top back then. Go figure.
Overall, solid work, with the additional bonuses on SOCIAL IQ and GONDOLA (part of a cable network, ha!) balancing out SASE, SDS, SHA. I appreciated that the juicy middle of the puzzle gave me an opportunity to do some thinking about why certain themeless feature entries shine, and others don't glow quite as brightly.