I was all set to deliver my usual "Will Shortz doesn't like themes where circled letters are all the same because they're too ...
read moreI was all set to deliver my usual "Will Shortz doesn't like themes where circled letters are all the same because they're too easy to fill in, and then the puzzle's over" — but it was hardly over! Yes, I could fill in every circle after the first two sets … but what did they mean? More importantly, what did EYES ON THE PRIZE have to do with anything? There are pairs of Is …
Wait, EYE C!
A pair of Is on top of various PRIZEs: TROPHY, CUP, MEDAL, and the revealer's own PRIZE. Clever idea, and I loved how the obviousness of the circles proved to be anything but.
Amazing find in TROPHY within ASTROPHYSICIST. Will isn't taking many "hidden words" themes these days, but a long finding like this is a prize-winner. Breezy phrase in ZOOMED ALONG, too, doing a great job of tucking in a MEDAL.
Even though CUP is only three letters, it's difficult to hide within a phrase. PLAYED CUPID unfortunately doesn't break CUP across two words, as is Will's usual requirement, but there aren't many possibilities, except the PUBLIC UPROAR that I fully endorse regarding Microsoft Windows' %$#!@! AUTOMATIC UPDATES.
Solid integration of the eight Is. It's an easy letter to grid around, but eight of them — in fixed positions — can make things much harder. Smooth results, with ILE as the only gluey bit as a direct result.
There are some repercussions: CIARDI crossing ADZES could be tough for newer solvers, and LOCI vs. FOCI often causes confusion. The LPGA gets press, but I could see how someone might think that the Female PGA could be right.
It's not often that a Tuesday surprises me, creeping up with such a gold MEDAL a-ha.