I'm getting hungry, with a DRINK, CHIPS, SANDWICH, and COOKIE neatly hidden in the grid. Sam did a great job of choosing themers that ...
read moreI'm getting hungry, with a DRINK, CHIPS, SANDWICH, and COOKIE neatly hidden in the grid. Sam did a great job of choosing themers that camouflaged what was going on — I particularly liked kicking things off with IN THE DRINK (slang for "overboard"). By the time I hit SMART COOKIE, I knew the theme, but I liked how the puzzle was able to hide its hand until near the end.

I did hitch a little at LUNCHBOXES, though. I wondered at first if it was necessary. Then I tried to imagine how a drink might fit into a lunchbox. Are those little metal boxes big enough to fit cans? Took me a while to remember that kids usually take along … juice boxes? Juice pouches? I wondered if LUNCH would have been a better revealer, if one was necessary.
A lot of fun material in the grid, TACO TRUCKS a favorite lunch destination for me. SNOPES gave the puzzle a fresh feel too, and YOSHI pushed the vibe even younger. I feel for the older generation who might have a rough go with the YOSHI / SNOPES / DYNE intersections, though. The DYNE is a legit unit of force, hinted at in the word "dynamometer" (device to measure engine output), but it's still a toughie.
Curious choice, Sam picking PITCHES WOO for his puzzle. Since Sam's a young guy, I wondered if this term is making a comeback? Sort of an ironic usage among the Gen Y crowd?
I'm rooting for GENO Smith of the Jets to become a Hall-of-Famer. Right now he's riding the bench behind Ryan Fitzpatrick, but he has so much potential to become a crossword staple, with his beautifully alternating consonant-vowel pattern. I can't upgrade him on the XWord Info Word List quite yet, unfortunately.
Fun idea with great themers hiding what was going on. If the reveal had been punchier somehow, this would have been in POW! contention.