Check out that big swath running from top left to bottom right! It's one thing to work in four nice long answers — SISTERS IN LAW ...
read moreCheck out that big swath running from top left to bottom right! It's one thing to work in four nice long answers — SISTERS IN LAW (with its sneaky plural NOT ending in S), ONLINE POKER, LADIES FIRST, and HOMESTEAD ACT — but check out how the pairs of entries are locked so cleanly together by all those six and seven-letter answers in the middle. The more I stare at it, the more impressed I am.

And crossing a double-stack of long answers into a triple-stack like APENNINES (the Italian range) / WENCESLAS (with a clever clue nodding to Carole King) / NEOLATIN = a real feat. Constructors usually try to separate all their stacks as far away as possible, but Patrick crosses them together so smoothly. (Yes, some solvers say EPEE gets overused in crosswords, but it's a perfectly legit word.)
There were a few long answers that I thought were just neutral — ENSCONCED … okay, just ENSCONCED. Pretty amazing.
Given the high bar Patrick has set for himself, I wasn't as taken with the top right and bottom left corners. They were nice bonuses — many constructors would have been happy with just the NW to SE swath — but STEALTHIER feels just neutral to me, and LENS COVERS doesn't hit my ear nearly as well as LENS CAPS.
Additionally, Patrick's layout in those corners uses many more three-letter words than usual, which tends to make the puzzle too easy. For example, if you have a three-letter word referring to a bathroom, it's going to start with L (LOO or LAV). And entries like ALE and ELM and LYE have been used so many times that it's tough to come up with a new and devious clue. Those two corners fell all too easily for my taste.
As always, I love Patrick's innovations and experimentation in grid design. So cool to always see him work with a totally new grid design.