Most of the time, Andrew produces triple stair-stacks — three long answers atop each other, shifted over in a stair-like pattern. ...
read moreMost of the time, Andrew produces triple stair-stacks — three long answers atop each other, shifted over in a stair-like pattern. Today he went double or nothing, using six of them in an extra-tall grid. I call it a winner! From PVC PIPING to ORANGEADE, each of the six answers is somewhere between solid and juicy. I wasn't aware of the BEER LEAGUE slang, but it makes sense. I'm hoping the sports in said BEER LEAGUEs are more of the cup stacking variety, not so much drunken flag football. I'm pre-calling the E.R. …
A football-shaped middle is hard enough to pull off, but to run two fantastic entries through it? SECRET RECIPES is snazzy, and the clue's misdirection toward a Tupperware lid makes it even better. IN-APP PURCHASE has that crazy string of three Ps.
Any constructor would be immensely proud of that central creation. To do it all with just minor EUR and YRS is jaw-dropping.
I wanted to give Andrew another POW! on the merit of the middle alone, as exciting as the Marshawn Beast Quake. I stutter-stepped too many times to do it, though:
- I didn't know BEER LEAGUE, and that's fine. It's two words I recognize, and it makes sense as a whole. Toss in EPICURES (isn't it "epicureans" usually?), though, plus old-timey STENOG and TARPONS, and I got a vibe of weirdness.
- ADEPTS AGARS OMEGAS, pluralizations that felt inelegant.
- I enjoy a good BEAR CLAW. I also enjoy a great Saturday wordplay clue. But do bears have fingers? Aren't they toes? As much as I enjoy trivia, this clue generated more confusion than devilish head-slapping.
Don't get me wrong; it's still a fantastic puzzle. If Andrew hadn't already won so many POW!s, I'd probably give him this one. I love when constructors stretch themselves, and going from three to six stair-stacked answers certainly qualifies.