It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker. Please consider supporting our site by purchasing an account.

New York Times, Saturday, November 21, 2015

Author: Natan Last
Editor: Will Shortz
Natan Last
TotalDebutLatestCollabs
247/17/20073/7/20184
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
4112097
ScrabbleRebusCirclePangram
1.59240

This puzzle:

Rows: 15, Columns: 15 Words: 66, Blocks: 32 Missing: {FJQVXZ} Spans: 3, (1 triple stack) This is puzzle # 16 for Mr. Last. NYT links: Across Lite PDF

Support XWord Info

Donation Amount

XWord Info is only possible when people like you choose to support it through donations.

Donate to get access to XWord Info for a year.

Benefits vary by donation level. Thank you!

Natan Last notes: This was my first attempt at a triple stack; I think I'd gotten scared away by the idea that they require bad shorter fill, but ... more
Natan Last notes:

This was my first attempt at a triple stack; I think I'd gotten scared away by the idea that they require bad shorter fill, but after finding this trio I knew I had to pursue it. I really like when themelesses open up into quadrants with space for shorter double stacks, which I've found gives you a lot of leeway to insert something fresh. Got lucky with the SW, though I tried to re-fill that corner for a while before I talked myself into allowing ETCHEDIN, which still has a funny ring to me.

On the cluing side, I'm happy a lot my clues made the final cut — YOGA PANTS, HOP ON POP, HAMPSHIRE were the ones I was most happy to see transfer. Will and Joel did a great job hacking away at my tendency, these days anyway, to write overlong trivia-laden clues :) We've got another editorial attempt to, maybe the phrase is "freshen up" the clue for MEN — this one feels as though there's more potential for empowerment.

Hope you enjoyed the puzzle! And if you're a woman interested in learning how to construct themelesses, I'd like to throw my hat in to the ring of constructors happy to mentor.

Jeff Chen notes: What a cool grid pattern! The triple-stack down the center plus a TON of long entries — a pair of long downs in the NW / SE and ... more
Jeff Chen notes:

What a cool grid pattern! The triple-stack down the center plus a TON of long entries — a pair of long downs in the NW / SE and an enormous number of long acrosses — made me eager to dive in. The central stack didn't disappoint, with THE NOTORIOUS B.I.G. (I said a prayer of thanks that it was Biggie and not some new rapper I'd need every cross for) next to HATERS GONNA HATE. AMERICAN APPAREL is good, too.

(ADDED NOTE: people have been asking me about the pic of Ruth Bader Ginsberg — she's got one of my favorite nicknames, "the Notorious RBG.")

The Notorious RBG

Neat to see long answers run straight through that triple-stack. YOGA PANTS is not only a great entry, but it becomes stellar when you add a clue like [They may be put on a stretcher]. That's clue of the year material for me — I kept wondering what kind of accident victim the clue was hinting at. ART SCENE / HOP ON POP / SHAKE ON IT / I DON'T BITE also running through the stack? Yes yes yes!

ESNE? And a cutesy clue attempting to beg forgiveness for such a fusty piece of crosswordese? No no no! Along with some very minor stuff like OTO, PDS, SEP, it demonstrates the eternal trade-off of going B.I.G. (and needing to use some crossword glue), or staying more conservative (and completely smooth). I imagine Natan agonized about that corner, with such a great number of long words connecting up in the NE … but also the dreaded ESNE.

RPG is an interesting one. I'm not much of a gamer these days, but role-playing games like D&D are very familiar to me. It's going to be a toughie for some, especially when crossing GUAPOS, a word pretty deep into Spanish.

BOLLYWOOD is a great way to launch a themeless. I liked the misleading plural in [Indian pictures]. I wasn't as hot as some of the other long entries, DOCTRINAL / ETCHED IN / HAPPENED more neutral in my eyes than assets. Still, with a whopping 19 (!) long entries, Natan still converts many of those slots into POW-quality material. It just wasn't quite enough for me to be able to look the other way and give it the award this week.

1
B
2
A
3
B
4
Y
5
T
6
H
7
A
8
N
9
E
10
O
11
A
12
K
13
P
O
L
L
O
14
H
A
M
P
S
15
H
I
R
E
16
A
L
L
A
Y
17
E
T
E
R
N
A
L
L
Y
18
C
L
U
B
O
19
W
N
E
R
20
E
P
E
E
S
21
K
Y
D
22
M
A
O
R
I
23
S
24
P
D
S
25
E
W
E
26
A
R
T
S
C
E
27
N
E
28
R
O
D
29
E
30
Y
O
G
A
P
A
N
31
T
32
S
33
S
O
T
T
34
O
35
R
O
N
36
N
E
H
I
37
S
38
D
O
C
T
39
R
I
N
A
40
L
41
D
A
D
E
42
H
O
P
O
N
P
O
43
P
44
T
E
D
45
D
46
O
E
47
G
U
A
P
O
S
48
S
K
A
49
B
I
R
D
50
S
51
S
H
A
K
E
52
O
N
I
T
53
R
O
S
I
E
54
S
B
A
R
55
U
P
I
C
E
56
I
D
O
N
T
B
I
T
E
57
D
E
C
K
S
58
M
E
N
59
H
A
G
E
L
60
O
N
E
S
© 2015, The New York TimesNo. 1121 ( 24,119 )
Across Down
1. Coddle : BABY
5. ___ of Glamis (Shakespearean epithet) : THANE
10. So-called "monarch of the forest" : OAK
13. Option at una taquería : POLLO
14. First U.S. college to divest from apartheid South Africa : HAMPSHIRE
16. Calm : ALLAY
17. Forever : ETERNALLY
18. Night-life industry bigwig : CLUBOWNER
20. Cousins of colichemardes : EPEES
21. Dramatist Thomas who was a contemporary of Shakespeare : KYD
22. People visited by Captain Cook in 1769 : MAORIS
24. Groups in blue, for short : PDS
25. Animal that Poseidon turned Theophane into, in myth : EWE
26. Bohemians are part of it : ARTSCENE
28. Went on : RODE
30. They may be put on a stretcher : YOGAPANTS
33. ___ voce : SOTTO
35. Wood of the Rolling Stones : RON
36. Beverages in orange, grape and peach flavors : NEHIS
38. Like matters of orthodoxy : DOCTRINAL
41. Florida's ___ Battlefield Historic State Park : DADE
42. Book with the line "My father can read big words, too. / Like Constantinople and Timbuktu" : HOPONPOP
44. "How I Met Your Mother" narrator : TED
45. Female kangaroo : DOE
47. Handsome hombres : GUAPOS
48. ___ punk (hybrid music genre) : SKA
49. Ones sending out tweets : BIRDS
51. Come to an agreement, say : SHAKEONIT
53. "M*A*S*H" watering hole : ROSIESBAR
55. Like some hockey passes : UPICE
56. "It's O.K., you can come closer" : IDONTBITE
57. Wallops : DECKS
58. "Luxuries," not "necessities," per Cher : MEN
59. Secretary of defense after Panetta : HAGEL
60. Low notes : ONES
1. Indian pictures : BOLLYWOOD
2. Referenced : ALLUDEDTO
3. Not be a good confidant : BLAB
4. Musician who performed at Obama's first inauguration : YOYOMA
5. "Mo Money Mo Problems" rapper : THENOTORIOUSBIG
6. Modern-day "You can't please everyone" : HATERSGONNAHATE
7. Los Angeles-based clothing giant : AMERICANAPPAREL
8. "This is ___" (broadcast tagline) : NPR
9. A slave to crosswords? : ESNE
10. Stewed : OILED
11. Much-painted city in Provence : ARLES
12. You might give them a ring : KEYS
13. Major pro team with the smallest home city : PACKERS
15. Went down : HAPPENED
19. Guarded : WARY
23. Intl. Day of Peace month : SEP
27. Old ___, "Game of Thrones" character : NAN
29. Forever a part of : ETCHEDIN
31. "Good for you" : THATSNICE
32. Seconds : SIDEKICKS
34. Plains folk : OTO
37. Calms : SEDATES
39. Dungeons & Dragons, e.g., for short : RPG
40. "Here's the thing ..." : LOOK
43. Fake : PSEUDO
45. Current path? : DIODE
46. Science fiction novelist ___ Scott Card : ORSON
49. Tipping point? : BRIM
50. Biblical character who lived 912 years : SETH
52. Welcome sign : OPEN
54. Loan-giving org. : SBA

Answer summary: 13 unique to this puzzle, 1 debuted here and reused later, 2 unique to Shortz Era but used previously.

Found bugs or have suggestions?